Name: Lauren King Student No.: n8281017 Tutors Name: Colleen Niland
BINGE DRINKING IN MEMBERS OF GENERATION Y-
HOW THE YOUTH OF TODAY ARE BECOMING THE HEALTH BURDEN OF TOMORROW.
CULTURAL ARTEFACT
The artefact that has been chosen to discuss is the song ‘Cheers (Drink to that)’ by Barbadian recording artist Rihanna. The song is categorised as a pop rock genre and was released on August 2nd 2011 to radio stations, and is off the fifth album Loud for Rihanna. The song and album has received mostly positive reviews for the pop singer who has been described as ‘one of the biggest pop stars in the world right now’, and has sold over 20 million albums worldwide (MTV US, 2011).
"Cheers (Drink To That)"- Rhianna
Cheers to the freaking weekend I drink to that, yeah yeah Oh let the Jameson sink in I drink to that, yeah yeah Don’t let the bastards get you down Turn it around with another round There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and I drink to that, I drink to that, I drink to that
Life’s too short to be sitting around miserable People gonna talk whether you doing bad or good, yeah Got a drink on my mind and my mind on my money, yeah Looking so bomb, gonna find me a honey Got my Ray-Bans on and I’m feeling hella cool tonight, yeah Everybody’s vibing so don’t nobody start a fight, yeah-ah-ah-ah
Cheers to the freaking weekend I drink to that, yeah yeah Oh let the Jameson sink in I drink to that, yeah yeah Don’t let the bastards get you down Turn it around with another round There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and I drink to that, I drink to that
‘Bout to hop on the bar, put it all on my card tonight, yeah Might be mad in the morning but you know we goin hard tonight It’s getting Coyote Ugly up in here, no Tyra It’s only up from here, no downward spiral Got my Ray-Bans on and I’m feeling hella cool tonight, yeah Everybody’s vibing so don’t nobody start a fight, yeah (yeah yeah)
Cheers to the freaking weekend I drink to that, yeah yeah Oh let the Jameson sink in I drink to that, yeah yeah Don’t let the bastards get you down Turn it around with another round There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and I drink to that, I drink to that
Cheers to the freaking weekend I drink to that, yeah yeah Oh let the Jameson sink in I drink to that, yeah yeah Don’t let the bastards get you down Turn it around with another round There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and I drink to that, I drink to that, I drink to that, I drink to that And I drink to that
THE PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUE
The Public health issue this song represents is the increasingly prevalent concern of binge drinking. The focus will be on the statistical evidence of binge drinking, and the connection between binge drinking and lifestyle choices, consequences, and the rise of binge drinking in members of Generation Y. As well as focusing on the effects of binge drinking, analysis into the changes between generations and the motives for binge drinking will be discussed, as well as any myths surrounding the public health issue of binge drinking.
LITERATURE REVIEW For many, drinking alcohol is a part of the Australian culture used to celebrate, commiserate and relax, with evidence reflecting it is considered an enjoyable way of socializing and counter-balancing the demands of daily hassles and routines (Van Wersch & Walker, 2009). However, binge drinking has recently come to the forefront as a major Public Health issue in Australia. According to the Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing, four Australians under the age of twenty five die from alcohol related injuries every week, and one quarter of all hospitalisations of 15 -25 year olds results because of the harmful effects of alcohol (Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing , 2011). Worldwide, 2.5 million deaths can be attributed to alcohol use, making it the third leading risk factor to health (Saxena, 2011). Binge Drinking is particularly harmful, and can lead to a number of long term complications (Victorian Government, 2011). The risks of binge drinking to society and individuals is clear and well publicised, yet the continued increase has become a serious public health issue costing $15 billion per year (Department of Health and Ageing , 2011) The Australian Government has recognised this harmful practice increasing in prevalence, pledging $55 million in 2008 to tackle the youth binge drinking epidemic, however, the effects of binge drinking are still evident through the behaviour of young Australians (Act Now, 2008).
Binge drinking can have several connotations, but for the purpose of this report is classified as ‘drinking heavily over a short period of time with the intention of becoming intoxicated, resulting in immediate and severe intoxication’ (Drug Info Clearinghouse , 2009 ). In the short term binge drinking can lead to nausea, vomiting, memory loss, aggression, assault, depression, and can also alter behaviour resulting in unsafe sexual encounters, violence and participation in dangerous behaviours. In the long term, binge drinking can result in alcohol dependence, some forms of cancer, and liver damage (Drug Info Clearinghouse , 2009 ).
According to the ABS ‘the proportion of people drinking at a risky/high risk level (seven or more standard drinks for males and five or more standard drinks for females on any single occasion) has increased over the past three National Health Surveys, from 8.2% in 1995 to 10.8% in 2001 and 13.4% in 2004-05’ (Australian Bureau of Statistics , 2006). Although this behaviour is evident across a number of survey respondents, a BEACH (Bettering the Evaluation and Care of Health ) study found the proportion of people who were binge drinkers decreased dramatically across age cohorts, and was highest in 18-24 year olds in which it was reported more than one third were regular binge drinkers (Charles, Valenti, & Miller, 2011). This was also confirmed in a comparison study between old drinkers vs. young drinkers, recognising that although older drinkers (aged between 50-65) binge drink on occasion, not nearly in as great amounts and as frequently as younger drinkers, confirming that this public health issue is age based (Wiscott, Kopera-Frye, & Begovic, 2002).
Evidence has shown that of those affected by binge drinking, in adolescents it is more common and more harmful (Weitzman, Nelson, & Wechsler, 2003 and Wiscott, Kopera-Frye, & Begovic, 2002). According to Drinkwise “From the age of 12 or 13 through to the early twenties the brain is in a state of intense development, moulding and hard wiring in readiness for the challenges of adulthood. Through a process called ‘frontalisation’ the brain is growing and forming all the critical parts it needs for learning, memory, planning, emotional stability and thinking. The new science tells us that alcohol disrupts brain development during this critical phase of growth. Teenagers who drink alcohol risk their brains not reaching full capacity, which means they might never reach their full potential as an adult” (Drinkwise Australia, 2010).
Although binge drinking has become an issue with a primary focus on Generation Y, parents have a great deal of impact on influencing the age their children begin drinking alcohol. There is evidence to suggest that the later adolescents consume their first alcoholic drink, the less likely they are to become regular consumers, and are less likely to become binge drinkers (Hayes, Smart, Toumbourou, & Sanson, 2004). Early onset and exposure to alcohol substantially increases the risk of criminal conviction, alcohol disorders, low education, earning less, and attributed with an increase in mental health problems later in life (Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2007).
Although a large amount of speculation is available about possible interventions or ‘blame games’ for the prevalence of binge drinking, there is no evidence about how political and current health promotion interventions have affected binge drinking rates (Flegel, MacDonald, & Hébert, 2011). According toDempster, Newell, Cowan (2006) the most positive results have been from “trauma based interventions” in high school age students.The aim of this kind of interventions is to change attitudes towards binge drinking and reduce the amount of alcohol consumed, rather than stopping alcohol consumption altogether (Dempster, Newell, Cowan, & Marley, 2006). Evidence suggests that high school age ‘trauma based’ interventions delay the age youth begin to drink by 6 months, and in particular, delay the beginning of binge drinking occurrences (Conrod, Castellanos, & Mackie, 2007). However, longitudinal studies are needed to establish the most effective interventions for binge drinking. These studies would also be needed to evaluate the burden of the increase of binge drinking for the health system, and the implications of this trend on the Australian health system. According to Van Wersch & Walker (2009) ‘more research on the health consequences of binge-drinking is needed, which acknowledges psychosocial contextual factors, and which avoids generalizations made on isolated biomedical data…. When looking at other cultures, it must be remembered that drinking patterns are interwoven in a web of cultural and social meanings. More attention needs to be given to macro level conditions in explanations of, and interventions aimed at reducing, binge-drinking.’ In a country like Australia, in which the drinking culture is ingrained into every aspect of society, it seems that researches and public health workers have a long way to go until this detrimental trend becomes realised. CULTURAL AND SOCIAL ANALYSIS To analyse and identify the reasons and causes behind binge drinking there are a number of social theories that feel they can explain the phenomenon, however, the two main theories have been applied in this essay- Social Learning Theory and Social Identity Theory. The first, Social Learning Theory, focuses on the learning that occurs in the social context, by observing, modelling, and reinforcing behaviour (Ormrod, 2005).According to Social Learning Theory ‘deviance’ is a learned behaviour, and when occurring in primary social groups, such as friends and family, has the biggest impact on individual’s behaviour (Durkin, Wolfe, & Clark, 2005) . This is particularly useful when discussing the context and affect family and peers have on an individual’s decision to binge drink. For example, parents or groups of peers partaking in binge drinking without consequences models to the individual that the behaviour is desirable, and could also include the individual as a part of the group for remodelling the behaviour (Ormrod, 2005).
Social identity theory could also be used in this context, identifying that group membership is affected by similar thoughts, feelings, actions and behaviours of the individual (University of Twente, 2010). This is reinforced through sociologist Irving Goffman’s Theory of symbolic interactions, claiming we were different ‘masks’ depending on the social group of the time (University of Hawaii, 2011). For Social Identity theory, the large amount of binge drinkers in certain settings or with certain people can be traced to how individuals identify themselves, and feel a sense of pride or belonging with certain groups based on their actions (Mcleod, 2008).
The most common assumption made is that those of Indigenous descent are more susceptible to binge drinking however, the ABS has found the proportion of Indigenous Australians binge drinking is similar to that of non- Indigenous Australians (Australian Bureau of Statistics , 2006). In reality, according to the United States Centre for Disease Control and Prevention highly educated 18- to 24-year- old males of Caucasian descent are the most likely to binge drink, and this figure rises substantially if the individual lives in a share house and attends university (Lopatto, 2011 &Almeida-Filho, et al., 2004).This reflects both Social Learning Theory and Social Identity theory, as the behaviour is observed and modelled, and is most common within a group setting.
It has also been theorised that the reason for the rise in Binge Drinking in members of Generation Y is due to the change in parenting skills. According to Professor Mike Daube from the McCusker Centre for Action on Alcohol and Youth "Young people have more freedom than ever before...They are more affluent, alcohol is more accessible, and it is heavily promoted..." (Lang, 2011). Generation Y were the first generation to receive a high level of permissive parenting in which parents have given their children more freedom at a younger age to assist them to become more mature and self-reliant (McCrindle, 2010). While possibly having the desired effect, this has also allowed Generation Y as children to discover an ‘adult world’ much more quickly (McCrindle, 2010). The effects of ‘permissive parenting’ are evident in research. Results from the Australian School Students' Alcohol and Drug Survey in 2002 found that 51% of children under the age of 18 are provided with alcohol by their parents, and alcohol is most likely to be consumed in the home (Hayes, Smart, Toumbourou, & Sanson, Parenting influences on adolescent alcohol use, 2011). According to Weitzman, Wetschler and Nelson (2003) young people who are exposed to “wet” environments were more likely to pick up binge drinking than their peers without similar exposures. Wet environments included family, friendship networks and affiliations in which binge drinking is common, endorsed, and easy to access (Weitzman, Nelson, & Wechsler, 2003).
There are a number of social trends and changes associated with categorising people into Generations based on similar characteristics, including monitoring the patterns of consumption. According to Drug and Alcohol Rehab Asia (2011), generational trends are evident in the use of alcohol and other drugs, and among current living generations, baby boomers and generation X are the most likely to abuse alcohol, whereas Generation Y (those born from early 80’s to the late 90’s) has lower rates of alcohol abuse, but higher rates of binge drinking (DARA – Drug & Alcohol Rehab Asia, 2011). The primary reason for this was trend was that binge drinking for Generation Y members is more socially acceptable, and treatment is less likely to be sought because the effects of binge drinking have not yet generated health problems in the younger generation.
In 1988 a report published by the Australian Commission for the Future outlined the effects of alcohol abuse and the consequent rise of the problem in youth if causes of the issue were not identified (Lang, 2011). Unfortunately, despite the increases in the federal budget for health, this problem has only substantiated in the years since the report was published (Lang, 2011).Unless treated, the widespread effects of binge drinking on the current generation will substantiate the burden of disease and long term side effects associated with binge drinking. This will include an increased burden on the already strained hospital system and emergency services due to an increase of alcohol related side effects, and if continued possibly have a detrimental effect on the life expectancy and health problems expected by Generation Y as they age. The government has identified binge drinking as a public health issue, commissioning a Ministerial Council on Drug Strategy to identify options to effectively reduce the prevalence of binge drinking in younger people, guided by the Centre for Applied Research Solutions, which identified through evidence four main focus areas to prevent binge drinking in adolescents: Strategic Use of Data, Community Organising, Policy Advocacy and Enforcement (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 2011). Public Health experts should also use their knowledge in collaboration with the Australian and State and Territory Governments to identify the most effective options to stop the increase of binge drinking particularly in young people, in which it is most prevalent and harmful, and realistic interventions to stop this increasing trend. Without appropriate steps taken to protect the younger generation from the harmful effects of binge drinking, the next generation will face substantial health and health system problems.
ANALYSIS AND LEARNING REFLECTIONS The artefact that was chosen to represent the issue of youth binge drinking is the song “Cheers (Drink to that)” by pop singer, Rihanna. Since her debut in 2005, Rihanna has sold more than 20 million albums and 60 million singles, making her one of the bestselling music artists of all time and securing her place as an international pop star (Billboard.com, 2011). Her song “Cheers (Drink to That)” was released on the 2nd of August 2011 has since reached Top Ten on the Billboard Charts in Australia and the United States, as well as a number of other countries (Billboard.com, 2011). The song was released as a ‘weekend drinking anthem’ in which Rihanna dedicated the song to “…all the semi alcoholics in the world” (Cheers (Drink to That): Rihanna releases a weekend drinking anthem, 2011).
The song “Cheers (Drink to That)” reflects a celebration at the end of the week, in particular using alcohol as a getaway. Through the chorus lyrics- “Don't let the bastards get ya down/Turn it around with another round…” the interpretation has been made that Rihanna believes enough alcohol can fix, and help forget all of life’s problems. The video clip of the song also depicts Rihanna drinking shots in front of a large audience cheering. This is a perfect example of the effect that influential media personalities can have on glamourizing binge drinking, while making it appear it is something ‘everyone is doing’. For a 23 year old platinum selling artist to release a top ten single glorifying binge drinking as a celebration, the message being sent to young people from someone they idolise, who is not much older than them, is potentially detrimental (Billboard.com, 2011). This song and video does not present the hazardous consequences that can come from binge drinking, instead presenting a glorified view of the fun and good times that can occur through the use of alcohol. Consequently, for younger children who idolise Rihanna as a role model this song also has the potential to seemingly ‘peer pressure’ children to begin drinking alcohol at a younger age.
Personally, before doing this assignment, I thought of this as just another pop song that would get stuck in my head. However, after reading the lyrics and analysing the song, I have come to realise the detrimental effects of the media on many public health issues. In particular, I have begun to listen to the meaning of songs and other media items, to find out the real message behind them, whereas previously I would have continued to sing loud and off-key. As a result of this assignment piece I have learnt to be more aware of social media and the messages that the articles may be trying to portray. Hopefully, the is a trait which will help me with my future studies, as I am becoming more aware of what is going on around me and the effects this could have.
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare . (2011). MAKING PROGRESS: THE HEALTH, DEVELOPMENT AND WELLBEING OF AUSTRALIA’S CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE: Adolescence (13–19 years). Retrieved October 9, 2011, from Australian Institute of Health and Welfare : www.aihw.gov.au/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=6442459898
Charles, J., Valenti, L., & Miller, G. (2011). Binge Drinking. Australian Family Physician, 569.
Conrod, P. J., Castellanos, N., & Mackie, C. (2007). Personality-targeted interventions delay the growth of adolescent drinking and binge drinking. Journal of child Psychology and Psychiatry, 49 (2), 181-191.
Durkin, K. F., Wolfe, T. W., & Clark, G. A. (2005). COLLEGE STUDENTS AND BINGE DRINKING: AN EVALUATION OF SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY. Sociological Spectrum, 25 (3), 255-272.
Flegel, K., MacDonald, N., & Hébert, P. C. (2011). Binge drinking: all too prevalent and hazardous. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 183 (4), 146.
Hayes, L., Smart, D., Toumbourou, J. W., & Sanson, A. (2004). Parenting influences on adolescent alcohol use. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies .
Hayes, L., Smart, D., Toumbourou, J. W., & Sanson, A. (2011). Parenting influences on adolescent alcohol use. Canberra: Australian Institute of Family Studies .
Lang, K. (2011, October 30). Sober Facts of Life. The Sunday Mail , p. 8.
Lopatto, E. (2011, January 14). Binge Drinking More Common Among Wealthier Americans, CDC Study Says. Bloomberg.
McCrindle, M. (2010, February 5). Many ingredients make this gen Y cocktail of violence. The Age .
Van Wersch, A., & Walker, W. (2009). Binge-drinking in Britain as a Social and Cultural Phenomenon : The Development of a Grounded Theoretical Model. Journal of Health Psychology, 14 (1), 124-134.
Weitzman, E. R., Nelson, T. F., & Wechsler, H. (2003). Taking up binge drinking in college: the influences of person, social group, and environment. Journal of Adolescent Health , 26-35.
Wiscott, R., Kopera-Frye, K., & Begovic, A. (2002). Binge Drinking in Later Life : Comparing Young-Old and Old-Old Social Drinkers. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 252-255.
Student No.: n8281017
Tutors Name: Colleen Niland
BINGE DRINKING IN MEMBERS OF GENERATION Y-
HOW THE YOUTH OF TODAY ARE BECOMING THE HEALTH BURDEN OF TOMORROW.CULTURAL ARTEFACT
The artefact that has been chosen to discuss is the song ‘Cheers (Drink to that)’ by Barbadian recording artist Rihanna. The song is categorised as a pop rock genre and was released on August 2nd 2011 to radio stations, and is off the fifth album Loud for Rihanna. The song and album has received mostly positive reviews for the pop singer who has been described as ‘one of the biggest pop stars in the world right now’, and has sold over 20 million albums worldwide (MTV US, 2011).
"Cheers (Drink To That)"- Rhianna
Cheers to the freaking weekend
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Oh let the Jameson sink in
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Don’t let the bastards get you down
Turn it around with another round
There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and
I drink to that, I drink to that, I drink to that
Life’s too short to be sitting around miserable
People gonna talk whether you doing bad or good, yeah
Got a drink on my mind and my mind on my money, yeah
Looking so bomb, gonna find me a honey
Got my Ray-Bans on and I’m feeling hella cool tonight, yeah
Everybody’s vibing so don’t nobody start a fight, yeah-ah-ah-ah
Cheers to the freaking weekend
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Oh let the Jameson sink in
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Don’t let the bastards get you down
Turn it around with another round
There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and
I drink to that, I drink to that
‘Bout to hop on the bar, put it all on my card tonight, yeah
Might be mad in the morning but you know we goin hard tonight
It’s getting Coyote Ugly up in here, no Tyra
It’s only up from here, no downward spiral
Got my Ray-Bans on and I’m feeling hella cool tonight, yeah
Everybody’s vibing so don’t nobody start a fight, yeah (yeah yeah)
Cheers to the freaking weekend
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Oh let the Jameson sink in
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Don’t let the bastards get you down
Turn it around with another round
There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and
I drink to that, I drink to that
Cheers to the freaking weekend
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Oh let the Jameson sink in
I drink to that, yeah yeah
Don’t let the bastards get you down
Turn it around with another round
There’s a party at the bar everybody put your glasses up and
I drink to that, I drink to that, I drink to that, I drink to that
And I drink to that
THE PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUE
The Public health issue this song represents is the increasingly prevalent concern of binge drinking. The focus will be on the statistical evidence of binge drinking, and the connection between binge drinking and lifestyle choices, consequences, and the rise of binge drinking in members of Generation Y. As well as focusing on the effects of binge drinking, analysis into the changes between generations and the motives for binge drinking will be discussed, as well as any myths surrounding the public health issue of binge drinking.
LITERATURE REVIEW
For many, drinking alcohol is a part of the Australian culture used to celebrate, commiserate and relax, with evidence reflecting it is considered an enjoyable way of socializing and counter-balancing the demands of daily hassles and routines (Van Wersch & Walker, 2009). However, binge drinking has recently come to the forefront as a major Public Health issue in Australia. According to the Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing, four Australians under the age of twenty five die from alcohol related injuries every week, and one quarter of all hospitalisations of 15 -25 year olds results because of the harmful effects of alcohol (Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing , 2011). Worldwide, 2.5 million deaths can be attributed to alcohol use, making it the third leading risk factor to health (Saxena, 2011). Binge Drinking is particularly harmful, and can lead to a number of long term complications (Victorian Government, 2011). The risks of binge drinking to society and individuals is clear and well publicised, yet the continued increase has become a serious public health issue costing $15 billion per year (Department of Health and Ageing , 2011) The Australian Government has recognised this harmful practice increasing in prevalence, pledging $55 million in 2008 to tackle the youth binge drinking epidemic, however, the effects of binge drinking are still evident through the behaviour of young Australians (Act Now, 2008).
Binge drinking can have several connotations, but for the purpose of this report is classified as ‘drinking heavily over a short period of time with the intention of becoming intoxicated, resulting in immediate and severe intoxication’ (Drug Info Clearinghouse , 2009 ). In the short term binge drinking can lead to nausea, vomiting, memory loss, aggression, assault, depression, and can also alter behaviour resulting in unsafe sexual encounters, violence and participation in dangerous behaviours. In the long term, binge drinking can result in alcohol dependence, some forms of cancer, and liver damage (Drug Info Clearinghouse , 2009 ).
According to the ABS ‘the proportion of people drinking at a risky/high risk level (seven or more standard drinks for males and five or more standard drinks for females on any single occasion) has increased over the past three National Health Surveys, from 8.2% in 1995 to 10.8% in 2001 and 13.4% in 2004-05’ (Australian Bureau of Statistics , 2006). Although this behaviour is evident across a number of survey respondents, a BEACH (Bettering the Evaluation and Care of Health ) study found the proportion of people who were binge drinkers decreased dramatically across age cohorts, and was highest in 18-24 year olds in which it was reported more than one third were regular binge drinkers (Charles, Valenti, & Miller, 2011). This was also confirmed in a comparison study between old drinkers vs. young drinkers, recognising that although older drinkers (aged between 50-65) binge drink on occasion, not nearly in as great amounts and as frequently as younger drinkers, confirming that this public health issue is age based (Wiscott, Kopera-Frye, & Begovic, 2002).
Evidence has shown that of those affected by binge drinking, in adolescents it is more common and more harmful (Weitzman, Nelson, & Wechsler, 2003 and Wiscott, Kopera-Frye, & Begovic, 2002). According to Drinkwise “From the age of 12 or 13 through to the early twenties the brain is in a state of intense development, moulding and hard wiring in readiness for the challenges of adulthood. Through a process called ‘frontalisation’ the brain is growing and forming all the critical parts it needs for learning, memory, planning, emotional stability and thinking. The new science tells us that alcohol disrupts brain development during this critical phase of growth. Teenagers who drink alcohol risk their brains not reaching full capacity, which means they might never reach their full potential as an adult” (Drinkwise Australia, 2010).
Although binge drinking has become an issue with a primary focus on Generation Y, parents have a great deal of impact on influencing the age their children begin drinking alcohol. There is evidence to suggest that the later adolescents consume their first alcoholic drink, the less likely they are to become regular consumers, and are less likely to become binge drinkers (Hayes, Smart, Toumbourou, & Sanson, 2004). Early onset and exposure to alcohol substantially increases the risk of criminal conviction, alcohol disorders, low education, earning less, and attributed with an increase in mental health problems later in life (Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2007).
Although a large amount of speculation is available about possible interventions or ‘blame games’ for the prevalence of binge drinking, there is no evidence about how political and current health promotion interventions have affected binge drinking rates (Flegel, MacDonald, & Hébert, 2011). According toDempster, Newell, Cowan (2006) the most positive results have been from “trauma based interventions” in high school age students.The aim of this kind of interventions is to change attitudes towards binge drinking and reduce the amount of alcohol consumed, rather than stopping alcohol consumption altogether (Dempster, Newell, Cowan, & Marley, 2006). Evidence suggests that high school age ‘trauma based’ interventions delay the age youth begin to drink by 6 months, and in particular, delay the beginning of binge drinking occurrences (Conrod, Castellanos, & Mackie, 2007). However, longitudinal studies are needed to establish the most effective interventions for binge drinking. These studies would also be needed to evaluate the burden of the increase of binge drinking for the health system, and the implications of this trend on the Australian health system. According to Van Wersch & Walker (2009) ‘more research on the health consequences of binge-drinking is needed, which acknowledges psychosocial contextual factors, and which avoids generalizations made on isolated biomedical data…. When looking at other cultures, it must be remembered that drinking patterns are interwoven in a web of cultural and social meanings. More attention needs to be given to macro level conditions in explanations of, and interventions aimed at reducing, binge-drinking.’ In a country like Australia, in which the drinking culture is ingrained into every aspect of society, it seems that researches and public health workers have a long way to go until this detrimental trend becomes realised.
CULTURAL AND SOCIAL ANALYSIS
To analyse and identify the reasons and causes behind binge drinking there are a number of social theories that feel they can explain the phenomenon, however, the two main theories have been applied in this essay- Social Learning Theory and Social Identity Theory. The first, Social Learning Theory, focuses on the learning that occurs in the social context, by observing, modelling, and reinforcing behaviour (Ormrod, 2005).According to Social Learning Theory ‘deviance’ is a learned behaviour, and when occurring in primary social groups, such as friends and family, has the biggest impact on individual’s behaviour (Durkin, Wolfe, & Clark, 2005) . This is particularly useful when discussing the context and affect family and peers have on an individual’s decision to binge drink. For example, parents or groups of peers partaking in binge drinking without consequences models to the individual that the behaviour is desirable, and could also include the individual as a part of the group for remodelling the behaviour (Ormrod, 2005).
Social identity theory could also be used in this context, identifying that group membership is affected by similar thoughts, feelings, actions and behaviours of the individual (University of Twente, 2010). This is reinforced through sociologist Irving Goffman’s Theory of symbolic interactions, claiming we were different ‘masks’ depending on the social group of the time (University of Hawaii, 2011). For Social Identity theory, the large amount of binge drinkers in certain settings or with certain people can be traced to how individuals identify themselves, and feel a sense of pride or belonging with certain groups based on their actions (Mcleod, 2008).
The most common assumption made is that those of Indigenous descent are more susceptible to binge drinking however, the ABS has found the proportion of Indigenous Australians binge drinking is similar to that of non- Indigenous Australians (Australian Bureau of Statistics , 2006). In reality, according to the United States Centre for Disease Control and Prevention highly educated 18- to 24-year- old males of Caucasian descent are the most likely to binge drink, and this figure rises substantially if the individual lives in a share house and attends university (Lopatto, 2011 &Almeida-Filho, et al., 2004).This reflects both Social Learning Theory and Social Identity theory, as the behaviour is observed and modelled, and is most common within a group setting.
It has also been theorised that the reason for the rise in Binge Drinking in members of Generation Y is due to the change in parenting skills.
According to Professor Mike Daube from the McCusker Centre for Action on Alcohol and Youth "Young people have more freedom than ever before...They are more affluent, alcohol is more accessible, and it is heavily promoted..." (Lang, 2011). Generation Y were the first generation to receive a high level of permissive parenting in which parents have given their children more freedom at a younger age to assist them to become more mature and self-reliant (McCrindle, 2010). While possibly having the desired effect, this has also allowed Generation Y as children to discover an ‘adult world’ much more quickly (McCrindle, 2010). The effects of ‘permissive parenting’ are evident in research. Results from the Australian School Students' Alcohol and Drug Survey in 2002 found that 51% of children under the age of 18 are provided with alcohol by their parents, and alcohol is most likely to be consumed in the home (Hayes, Smart, Toumbourou, & Sanson, Parenting influences on adolescent alcohol use, 2011). According to Weitzman, Wetschler and Nelson (2003) young people who are exposed to “wet” environments were more likely to pick up binge drinking than their peers without similar exposures. Wet environments included family, friendship networks and affiliations in which binge drinking is common, endorsed, and easy to access (Weitzman, Nelson, & Wechsler, 2003).
There are a number of social trends and changes associated with categorising people into Generations based on similar characteristics, including monitoring the patterns of consumption. According to Drug and Alcohol Rehab Asia (2011), generational trends are evident in the use of alcohol and other drugs, and among current living generations, baby boomers and generation X are the most likely to abuse alcohol, whereas Generation Y (those born from early 80’s to the late 90’s) has lower rates of alcohol abuse, but higher rates of binge drinking (DARA – Drug & Alcohol Rehab Asia, 2011). The primary reason for this was trend was that binge drinking for Generation Y members is more socially acceptable, and treatment is less likely to be sought because the effects of binge drinking have not yet generated health problems in the younger generation.
In 1988 a report published by the Australian Commission for the Future outlined the effects of alcohol abuse and the consequent rise of the problem in youth if causes of the issue were not identified (Lang, 2011). Unfortunately, despite the increases in the federal budget for health, this problem has only substantiated in the years since the report was published (Lang, 2011).Unless treated, the widespread effects of binge drinking on the current generation will substantiate the burden of disease and long term side effects associated with binge drinking. This will include an increased burden on the already strained hospital system and emergency services due to an increase of alcohol related side effects, and if continued possibly have a detrimental effect on the life expectancy and health problems expected by Generation Y as they age. The government has identified binge drinking as a public health issue, commissioning a Ministerial Council on Drug Strategy to identify options to effectively reduce the prevalence of binge drinking in younger people, guided by the Centre for Applied Research Solutions, which identified through evidence four main focus areas to prevent binge drinking in adolescents: Strategic Use of Data, Community Organising, Policy Advocacy and Enforcement (Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, 2011). Public Health experts should also use their knowledge in collaboration with the Australian and State and Territory Governments to identify the most effective options to stop the increase of binge drinking particularly in young people, in which it is most prevalent and harmful, and realistic interventions to stop this increasing trend. Without appropriate steps taken to protect the younger generation from the harmful effects of binge drinking, the next generation will face substantial health and health system problems.
ANALYSIS AND LEARNING REFLECTIONS
The artefact that was chosen to represent the issue of youth binge drinking is the song “Cheers (Drink to that)” by pop singer, Rihanna. Since her debut in 2005, Rihanna has sold more than 20 million albums and 60 million singles, making her one of the bestselling music artists of all time and securing her place as an international pop star (Billboard.com, 2011). Her song “Cheers (Drink to That)” was released on the 2nd of August 2011 has since reached Top Ten on the Billboard Charts in Australia and the United States, as well as a number of other countries (Billboard.com, 2011). The song was released as a ‘weekend drinking anthem’ in which Rihanna dedicated the song to “…all the semi alcoholics in the world” (Cheers (Drink to That): Rihanna releases a weekend drinking anthem, 2011).
The song “Cheers (Drink to That)” reflects a celebration at the end of the week, in particular using alcohol as a getaway. Through the chorus lyrics- “Don't let the bastards get ya down/Turn it around with another round…” the interpretation has been made that Rihanna believes enough alcohol can fix, and help forget all of life’s problems. The video clip of the song also depicts Rihanna drinking shots in front of a large audience cheering. This is a perfect example of the effect that influential media personalities can have on glamourizing binge drinking, while making it appear it is something ‘everyone is doing’. For a 23 year old platinum selling artist to release a top ten single glorifying binge drinking as a celebration, the message being sent to young people from someone they idolise, who is not much older than them, is potentially detrimental (Billboard.com, 2011). This song and video does not present the hazardous consequences that can come from binge drinking, instead presenting a glorified view of the fun and good times that can occur through the use of alcohol. Consequently, for younger children who idolise Rihanna as a role model this song also has the potential to seemingly ‘peer pressure’ children to begin drinking alcohol at a younger age.
Personally, before doing this assignment, I thought of this as just another pop song that would get stuck in my head. However, after reading the lyrics and analysing the song, I have come to realise the detrimental effects of the media on many public health issues. In particular, I have begun to listen to the meaning of songs and other media items, to find out the real message behind them, whereas previously I would have continued to sing loud and off-key. As a result of this assignment piece I have learnt to be more aware of social media and the messages that the articles may be trying to portray. Hopefully, the is a trait which will help me with my future studies, as I am becoming more aware of what is going on around me and the effects this could have.
Rihanna in an onstage performance
LINKS
Current advertising strategies to stop the rise of binge drinking:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jftfU30xJg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuowE1SXNkA
Current affairs reports into the rise of young women binge drinking:
http://sixtyminutes.ninemsn.com.au/stories/tarabrown/637045/girls-will-be-boys
http://sixtyminutes.ninemsn.com.au/stories/8290711/wasted
Current Australian Advertising:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkScHtrowM8&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJNNtsJmZb4&feature=related
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing . (2011). Teacher notes - National Binge Drinking Campaign. Retrieved September 22, 2011, from Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing : http://www.drinkingnightmare.gov.au/internet/drinkingnightmare/publishing.nsf/Content/teacher-notes
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare . (2011). MAKING PROGRESS: THE HEALTH, DEVELOPMENT AND WELLBEING OF AUSTRALIA’S CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE: Adolescence (13–19 years). Retrieved October 9, 2011, from Australian Institute of Health and Welfare : www.aihw.gov.au/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=6442459898
Billboard.com. (2011). Rihanna- Biography. Retrieved October 14, 2011, from Billboard.com: http://www.billboard.com/song/rihanna/cheers-drink-to-that/23241716#/artist/rihanna/bio/658897
Charles, J., Valenti, L., & Miller, G. (2011). Binge Drinking. Australian Family Physician, 569.
Conrod, P. J., Castellanos, N., & Mackie, C. (2007). Personality-targeted interventions delay the growth of adolescent drinking and binge drinking. Journal of child Psychology and Psychiatry, 49 (2), 181-191.
DARA – Drug & Alcohol Rehab Asia. (2011). Generational Trends in Substance Abuse. Retrieved September 27, 2011, from DARA – Drug & Alcohol Rehab Asia: http://alcoholrehab.com/alcohol-rehab/substance-abuse-generational-trends/
Dempster, M., Newell, G., Cowan, G., & Marley, J. (2006). Reducing binge drinking in adolescent males. British Dental Journal, 587-590.
Department of Health and Ageing . (2011). Changing the Drinking Culture in Australia. Retrieved September 23, 2011, from Department of Health and Ageing : http://www.health.gov.au/internet/preventativehealth/publishing.nsf/Content/09C94C0F1B9799F5CA2574DD0081E770/$File/alcohol-1.pdf
Drinkwise Australia. (2010). Kids and Alcohol don’t mix. Retrieved October 4, 2011, from Drinkwise Australia: http://www.drinkwise.org.au/c/dw?a=sendfile&ft=p&fid=1310374194&sid
Drug Info Clearinghouse . (2009 , June). The facts about binge drinking. Retrieved September 23, 2011, from Drug Info Clearinghouse : http://www.druginfo.adf.org.au/attachments/072_FS_1.10_binge.pdf
Durkin, K. F., Wolfe, T. W., & Clark, G. A. (2005). COLLEGE STUDENTS AND BINGE DRINKING: AN EVALUATION OF SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY. Sociological Spectrum, 25 (3), 255-272.
Flegel, K., MacDonald, N., & Hébert, P. C. (2011). Binge drinking: all too prevalent and hazardous. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 183 (4), 146.
Hayes, L., Smart, D., Toumbourou, J. W., & Sanson, A. (2004). Parenting influences on adolescent alcohol use. Melbourne: Australian Institute of Family Studies .
Hayes, L., Smart, D., Toumbourou, J. W., & Sanson, A. (2011). Parenting influences on adolescent alcohol use. Canberra: Australian Institute of Family Studies .
Lang, K. (2011, October 30). Sober Facts of Life. The Sunday Mail , p. 8.
Lopatto, E. (2011, January 14). Binge Drinking More Common Among Wealthier Americans, CDC Study Says. Bloomberg.
McCrindle, M. (2010, February 5). Many ingredients make this gen Y cocktail of violence. The Age .
Mcleod, S. (2008). Social Identity Theory. Retrieved October 5, 2011, from Simply Pshychology:Psychology Academic Articles for students: http://www.simplypsychology.org/social-identity-theory.html
MTV US. (2011). Rihanna . Retrieved October 11, 2011, from MTV: http://www.mtv.com/music/artist/rihanna/artist.jhtml
Ormrod, J. (2005). Social Learning Theory. Retrieved October 6, 2011, from The University of Texas at Austin : http://teachnet.edb.utexas.edu/~Lynda_abbot/Social.html
Saxena, S. (2011, March 15). Worldwide alcohol trends. (V. Riemer, Interviewer)
University of Hawaii. (2011, August 25). Irving Goffman. Retrieved October 5, 2011, from University of Hawaii: http://www2.hawaii.edu/~fm/goffman.html
University of Twente. (2010, September 7). Social Identity Theory. Retrieved October 6, 2011, from University of Twente: http://www.utwente.nl/cw/theorieenoverzicht/Theory%20clusters/Interpersonal%20Communication%20and%20Relations/Social_Identity_Theory.doc/
Van Wersch, A., & Walker, W. (2009). Binge-drinking in Britain as a Social and Cultural Phenomenon : The Development of a Grounded Theoretical Model. Journal of Health Psychology, 14 (1), 124-134.
Victorian Government. (2011, August 19). Youth Central. Retrieved October 4, 2011, from Binge Drinking : http://www.youthcentral.vic.gov.au/Health+&+Relationships/Drugs,+smoking+&+alcohol/Binge+drinking/
Weitzman, E. R., Nelson, T. F., & Wechsler, H. (2003). Taking up binge drinking in college: the influences of person, social group, and environment. Journal of Adolescent Health , 26-35.
Wiscott, R., Kopera-Frye, K., & Begovic, A. (2002). Binge Drinking in Later Life : Comparing Young-Old and Old-Old Social Drinkers. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 252-255.
COMMENTS ON THE WORK OF OTHERS